SC disposes of former PM Nawaz's review petition in judge video scandal case
SC says observations of top court have no bearing on current appeal in high court against Al Aziziya verdict
December 10, 2019
The Supreme Court of Pakistan on Tuesday disposed of a petition filed by former prime minister Nawaz Sharif seeking a review of an August 23 verdict by the top court regarding a video scandal involving former accountability court judge Mohammad Arshad Malik.
The top court had on August 23 declared that a video purportedly showing former accountability court judge Arshad Malik making compromising statements about a criminal case was not admissible as evidence until the authenticity of the video was established.
In its August 23 ruling, the top court had directed the petitioner, Ishtiaq Ahmed, to refer to the Islamabad High Court with his plea.
A three-member bench of the top court, headed by Chief Justice Asif Saeed Khosa and comprising Justice Sardar Tariq Masood and Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah, heard arguments on Tuesday morning.
In his remarks during the hearing, Justice Khosa sought to dispel the impression that the order regarding the video scandal would have any bearing on the authority of the Islamabad High Court to deliver a verdict in the ongoing case. "The high court is independent in making decisions,' Justice Khosa said.
Addressing the counsel for Nawaz Sharif, Khawaja Haris, in the SC during the hearing today, Justice Khosa said that the arguments made in the review petition had already been admitted by the court in an earlier verdict, and admonished Haris for not reading that ruling.
In its August 23 verdict, the SC had observed that the video involving former judge Arshad Malik could only be submitted as evidence in court by former PM Nawaz if the authenticity of it was established beyond doubt in front of the Islamabad High Court.
The IHC is currently hearing an appeal filed by the former premier into his conviction in the Al-Azizia reference. The video being shared by the Sharif family in court argues that former judge Arshad Malik was pressured into giving a verdict against Nawaz in the Al Aziziya reference.
