The power of rationality

If one were to choose a sequence of essentials for a nation to prosper, I would put rationality of their thought process on top. It is my firm belief that, without exercising this power, a state is left with little credibility to improve its lot, or that of its citizens.

It is also unfortunate that, since gaining independence, the assets that we have continually compromised are the very credentials of that momentous day. In addition to rendering them subservient to some ill-conceived compulsions emanating from foreign countries, we have also compromised them by practising policies aimed at aggrandising personal profits in preference to securing collective national interests. Today, we come across as a captive state banking for sustenance more on support that we can garner from outside than from internal effort embedded in unity and cohesion. Such an outlay makes for a cardinal sign of weakness, not strength.

To reap the fruits of our independence, one should revisit the speech that Quaid made from the floor of the first constituent assembly of the country on August 11, 1947, as also many others including the one where he addressed the civil service officers in Peshawar. He was clear and candid in spelling out the essentials the newborn state should espouse.

He underlined the centrality of freedom as equal citizens of the country beyond the confines of faith, caste, colour or creed. He went on to emphasise the sovereignty of the legislative body and the huge responsibility it places on the shoulders of the leaders to defend it. He dubbed bribery and corruption as curses and stressed the need to eliminate them.

Addressing the civil servants in Peshawar, he exhorted them not to fall victim to any pressure and do their duty as servants of the state and the people, and not the government in power at a particular time.

If one were to conduct an objective analysis of the happenings of the past decades, one would know that these are the very values which have been barbarously bartered for personal gains. Through a sinister process of politicisation of state interests, the concept of freedom, sanctity of the civil and other services and the need to protect the sovereignty of the state have all been compromised at the altar of enhancing personal wealth and power of the ruling elite and their crony cohorts.

While the state has suffered in terms of economic solvency and loss of stature among the comity of nations, it is the people who have borne the brunt of a spate of these misdemeanours by losing their dignity and self-respect on the one hand and the prospect of their growth and progress on the other.

The principal cause of all these belittlements can be traced to the placement of unnecessary curbs on the freedom of thought of the people. Intellectual activity and engagement create the space needed for nations to recognise their true destiny and chart a course to achieve it. By degrading people to be led as brainless lambs by the corrupt ruling elite, the national landscape would be rendered barren of ideas and momentum. Stagnation would automatically set in, which breeds nausea.

It is incumbent that such intellectual activity may cultivate multiple narratives which may be quite dissimilar from one another, but each one of them would carry its own weight. When the objective is clear, this diversity emerges as the essence of the intellectual thought process. We don’t cast stones at those with whom we may differ. We don’t lash them with invective-laden accusations. We don’t hand them a charge sheet, castigate them as traitors and force them into alienation from the societal mainstream. Like everyone else, they deserve to be there to make their contribution and help the state move forward.

While this has been a consistent tradition through the years of our existence, we have recently witnessed a rapid escalation in the scope of these curbs, which have stymied the prospect of our intellectual growth and consequent national salvation. A palpable fear syndrome pervades the environment, forcing people to resort to either staying locked in waiting for some improvement to set in, or plan on leaving the country by raising money through liquidating their paltry assets.

With close to four million people reported to have left in the last three years, this emigration amounts to a mass exodus, manifesting paucity of hope that a majority of citizens attach to living here. No state can prosper amidst such depressing conditions.

In the process, sanity and rationality become the principal victims. As the world becomes increasingly divided, there is a growing need to prioritise pragmatic and wise thinking for building a sustainable platform to deal with the emerging challenges. But the opposite seems to be the pattern where a counter opinion, born out of concern and sincerity, is construed as adverse to national interests and the individual is subjected to the harshest treatment, not excluding the possibility of spending time in jail, using a sequence of vicious legislations which are being adopted with alarming frequency. Already, the institution of an independent judiciary has been dealt a death knell, thus burying the possibility of the provision of justice in the country.

These conditions are not conducive to generating political stability, which imperils the prospect of economic growth. We have been dependent on support from international institutions and dole-outs from friendly countries. Instead of envisaging steps to decrease and ultimately eliminate this embarrassing dependence on outside sources, this scourge is increasing with time. As a matter of fact, every financial support secured from any quarter is touted as a great achievement and celebrated in glowing terms. Such behaviour is not just depressing; it is profoundly humiliating.

We need to get back to the basics. Not only have we forgotten our foundational ideals, but we have built a monstrous structure that rests on borrowed pillars. In the absence of internal cohesion and unity, as well as any genuine effort to address these issues, we are likely to continue declining. The governance approach requires a comprehensive overhaul.

The objective of a stable and self-reliant state cannot be achieved by blocking intellectual space with coercive measures. We should explore the power of rationality to unite people in an environment of peace and security, free from the threat of violence. Equally important is the need to stop insulting them by labelling them terrorists and traitors. They are not. They only exercise their right to differ.

Disclaimer: The viewpoints expressed in this piece are the writer's own and don't necessarily reflect Geo.tv's editorial policy.

The writer is a political and security strategist and the founder of the Regional Peace Institute. He is a former special assistant to former PM Imran Khan and heads the PTI’s policy think-tank. He tweets @RaoofHasan

Originally published in The News