Can't connect right now! retry

Tuesday Jul 02 2019

Company must compensate employee for reading Whatsapp chats: Swiss court

Silhouettes of mobile phone and laptop users are seen next to a screen projection of WhatsApp logo, March 18, 2018. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/Files

ZURICH: A Swiss court has ruled that a company, which fired its employee after nonconsensually reading her WhatsApp chats in which she had criticised her boss, must pay her 25,000 Swiss francs ($25,345), including her costs for fighting an appeal.

The Zurich Upper Court said the firm violated her right to privacy by illegally inspecting the chats. It upheld a lower labour court's ruling in deciding the company, whose name was not made public, inappropriately opened the chats and made copies of them during a routine check of employees’ business mobile phones for defects and unauthorized software.

According to court documents, the company must pay the fired worker more than 25,000 Swiss francs, including her costs for fighting an appeal brought by the firm that objected to the original decision handed down last August.

“Specific chats were opened and searched, without there being any suspicion or getting consent,” the court wrote in its 29-page decision released this week.

“It should be noted that a WhatsApp chat between two people, as opposed to Facebook entries, is missing elements that lend it the character of public communication.”

While the court did not give specifics about the messages sent via WhatsApp, a unit of Facebook, the company accused the administrative assistant of sending a colleague messages about her boss — with whom she shared an office — that amounted to sexual harassment.

The company, which court documents said provides personnel services in the health care sector, took screenshots of the WhatsApp messages to underpin its decision to sack the employee.

The court wrote it would have been more reasonable to simply delete WhatsApp, if the firm determined the social media app violated its rules against personal use of a company-provided device during work hours.

The employee, who worked at the firm from 2012 until her firing in June 2017, was also accused of feigning illness to skip work, betraying business secrets and bullying another worker.

The court, however, decided the company crossed the line and encroached on her privacy, which took priority or at least carried equal weight balanced against others’ interests in the case.

The court decided there was “no legal basis in the employment regulations which justified such a search of the mobile phone,” while adding the company can still appeal to the Swiss Federal Tribunal.

($1 = 0.9864 Swiss francs)

Notification Management

Tv Shows

Subscribe to desktop notification
Powered by IMM