Faizabad sit-in inquiry commission report is neither authentic nor reliable: Khawaja Asif

Commission was a joke as Lt Gen (retd) Hamid and Gen (retd) Bajwa didn't appear before it, says defence minister

Web Desk
Defence minister Khawaja Asif in an interview with BBC Urdu. — X/@FarhatJavedR
Defence minister Khawaja Asif in an interview with BBC Urdu. — X/@FarhatJavedR
  • Faizabad inquiry commission has exonerated Lt Gen (retd) Hamid. 
  • Asif says Hamid, ex-army chief didn't appear before commission. 
  • Faizabad sit-in inquiry commission was led by three members.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif said that the report made by the inquiry commission established to investigate the Faizabad sit-in holds no value as it is neither authentic nor reliable. 

He made these comments after the Faizabad sit-in inquiry commission exonerated former Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) director general Lieutenant General (retd) Faiz Hamid in its report. 

Speaking during an interview with a private TV channel, Asif said: "Faizabad commission was a joke as Generel (retd) Hamid and former army chief Gen (retd) Qamar Javed Bajwa did not appear before the commission but only political workers like me did."

The defence minister said that when he appeared before the commission, he realised that there was no seriousness there. 

"The Faizabad inquiry commission must introspect about whether it fulfilled its duty or not," he added.

The Faizabad sit-in commission, which was constituted on Supreme Court orders following the case pertaining to the 2017 sit-in at Faizabad led by former Tehreek-e-Labbaik Pakistan (TLP) chief Khadim Hussain Rizvi, gave a clean chit to the former spymaster and former Punjab Rangers director general Major General (retd) Azhar Naveed Hayat.

Both the former military officers were alleged of distributing money among participants of the sit-in protest in the federal capital. At the time of the protest, Hamid was heading ISI's counter intelligence wing and held the rank of a major general.

The commission was led by Dr Akhtar Ali Shah, a former officer of the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Police, and included senior PAS official Khushhal Khan and former inspector general Tahir Alam.

The inquiry body found out that then-army chief and ISI director general had given Hamid permission to sign the agreement as an arbitrator. Former prime minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi and former interior minister Ahsan Iqbal had also agreed to signing of the accord by Hamid on November 25, 2017, following which the demonstrators dispersed.

The probe body was tasked with identifying the perpetrators who facilitated the sit-in. However, it simply suggested taking legal action against the individuals in light of the federal government and Punjab's findings. 

In November last year, the caretaker federal government constituted the inquiry commission for the implementation of the top court’s 2019 Faizabad verdict.

The probe panel was constituted on the order of the Supreme Court under the chair of retired IGP Akhtar Ali Shah after the apex court rejected the fact-finding committee report constituted by the government.

Faizabad verdict

In November 2017, the top court took suo motu notice of the three-week-long sit-in, which was held against a change in the finality-of-Prophethood oath, termed by the government as a clerical error, when the government passed the Elections Act 2017.

The sit-in was called off after the protesters reached an agreement with the government.

On February 6, 2019, a two-member bench of the apex court comprising recommended that persons, issuing an edict or fatwa to harm another person or put another person in harm’s way must be dealt with an iron hand and prosecuted under relevant laws.

It also ruled that the intelligence agencies must not exceed their respective mandates. Later, the bench disposed of the suo motu case regarding the Faizabad sit-in.